Winner 2025 (Tie): Ammirati’s of Love Lane
Ammirati’s of Love Lane 135 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-7812 ammiratisoflovelane.com
Winner 2025: Black Sheep Bagels
Black Sheep Bagels 1451 Main Road, Jamesport (631) 779-2914 blacksheepbagelsnf.com
Winner 2025 (Tie): 1943 Pizza Bar
1943 Pizza Bar 308 Main St Unit D, Greenport (631) 477-6984 rollingindoughpizza.com/1943-pizza
Winner 2025: Modern Snack Bar
Modern Snack Bar 628 Main Rd, Riverhead (631) 722-3655 modernsnackbar.com
Winner 2025: The Village Cheese Shop
The Village Cheese Shop 105 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-8556 thevillagecheeseshop.com
Winner 2025: Magic Fountain
Magic Fountain 9825 Main Rd, Mattituck (631) 298-4908 magicfountainlongisland.com
Winner 2025: Cliff’s Elbow Room
Cliff’s Elbow Room 1549 Main Rd, Jamesport (631) 722-3292 cliffselbowroom.com
Winner 2025: Wowak Farms
Wowak Farms 2805 Main Rd, Laurel (631) 298-1495
Winner 2025: Ali Katz Kitchen
Ali Katz Kitchen 55 County Rd 48, Mattituck (631) 298-7694 alikatzkitchen.com
Winner 2025: Barrow Food House
Barrow Food House 452 Main Road, Aquebogue (631) 259-6472 barrowfoodhouse.com