Winner 2025: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com
Winner 2024: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com
Winner 2023: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com
Winner 2022: Disset Chocolate (Atelier Disset)
Disset Chocolate (Atelier Disset) 28080 Main Rd Cutchogue (631) 734-8387 dissetchocolate.com
Winner 2021: The Candyman
The Candyman22350 Main RdOrient631-323-2675