Winner 2025 (Tie): Ammirati’s of Love Lane
Ammirati’s of Love Lane 135 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-7812 ammiratisoflovelane.com
Winner 2025 (Tie): Wendy’s Deli
Wendy’s Deli 55 Middle Rd Unit 48, Mattituck (631) 400-3467 instagram.com/wendysdelimattituck
Winner 2024: Polka Deli
Polka Deli 125 W Main St Riverhead (631) 369-2102
Winner 2023: Wendy’s Deli
Wendy’s Deli 55 Middle Rd Unit 48 Mattituck (631) 400-3467 instagram.com/wendysdelimattituck
Winner 2022: Wendy’s Deli
Wendy’s Deli 55 Middle Rd Unit 48 Mattituck (631) 400-3467 instagram.com/wendysdelimattituck
Winner 2021: Ammirati’s of Love Lane
Ammirati’s of Love Lane135 Love LnMattituck631-298-7812 ammiratisoflovelane.com