Winner 2025: Lucharitos
Lucharitos 119 Main St, Greenport (631) 477-6666 lucharitos.com/greenport
Winner 2024: Little Lucharitos
Little Lucharitos 487 Main Rd Unit D Aquebogue (631) 779-3681 lucharitos.com/aquebogue
Winner 2023: Little Lucharitos (Tie)
Little Lucharitos 487 Main Rd Unit D Aquebogue (631) 779-3681 lucharitos.com/aquebogue
Winner 2022: Little Lucharitos
Little Lucharitos 487 Main Rd Unit D Aquebogue (631) 779-3681 lucharitos.com/aquebogue
Winner 2021: Pearl Restaurant & Bar
Pearl Restaurant & Bar409 Main StGreenport631-333-2888 pearlrestaurant409.square.site