Winner 2025 (Tie): Wendy’s Deli
Wendy’s Deli 55 Middle Rd Unit 48, Mattituck (631) 400-3467 instagram.com/wendysdelimattituck
Winner 2025: Billy’s by the Bay
Billy’s by the Bay 2530 Manhanset Ave, Greenport (631) 477-8300 billysbythebayrestaurant.com
Winner 2025: Stirling Sake
Stirling Sake 477 Main St, Greenport (631) 477-6782 stirlingsake.com
Winner 2025: Brix & Rye
Brix & Rye 308 Main St, Greenport (631) 477-6985 brixandrye.com
Winner 2025: Little Fish
Little Fish 50 North Sea Drive, Southold (631) 765-8756 littlefishnofo.com
Winner 2025: Front Street Station
Front Street Station 212 Front St, Greenport (631) 333-2050 eatatfrontstreet.net
Winner 2025: Riverhead Beverage
Riverhead Beverage 998 Osborn Ave, Riverhead (631) 727-0440 riverheadbeverage.com
Winner 2025: The Treatery Long Island
The Treatery Long Island 1564 Main Road, Jamesport (631) 779-2883 thetreateryli.com
Winner 2025: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com
Winner 2025: Pete’s Taverna
Pete’s Taverna 3225 Sound Avenue, Riverhead (631) 353-8500 petestavernarestaurantandbar.com