Winner 2023: Black Sheep Bagels
Black Sheep Bagels Multiple Locations (631) 779-2914 blacksheepbagelsnf.com
Winner 2023: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com
Winner 2023: Fit-Foods
Fit-Foods 46025 County Rd 48 Southold (631) 765-8199 fitfoodsnofo.com
Winner 2023: Riverhead Ciderhouse (Tie)
Riverhead Ciderhouse 2711 Sound Ave Calverton (631) 591-0217 riverheadcider.com
Winner 2023: Cliff’s Elbow Room
Cliff’s Elbow Room 1549 Main Rd Jamesport (631) 722-3292 cliffselbowroom.com
Winner 2023: Little Lucharitos
Little Lucharitos 487 Main Rd Unit D Aquebogue (631) 779-3681 lucharitos.com/aquebogue
Winner 2023: Magic Fountain
Magic Fountain 9825 Main Rd Mattituck (631) 298-4908 magicfountainlongisland.com
Winner 2023: Southold Fish Market
Southold Fish Market Rte 25 Southold (631) 765-3200 facebook.com/southoldfishmarket
Winner 2023: Ali Katz Kitchen
Ali Katz Kitchen 55 County Rd 48 Mattituck (631) 298-7694 alikatzkitchen.com
Winner 2023: Southold Fish Market
Southold Fish Market 64755 NY-25 Southold (631) 765-3200 facebook.com/southoldfishmarket