Winner 2023: The Treatery
The Treatery 1564 Main Road Jamesport (631) 779-2883 thetreateryli.com
Winner 2022: The Village Cheese Shop
The Village Cheese Shop 105 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-8556 thevillagecheeseshop.com
Winner 2022: Stirling Sake
Stirling Sake 477 Main St Greenport (631) 477-6782 stirlingsake.com
Winner 2022: Southold Fish Market
Southold Fish Market 64755 NY-25 Southold (631) 765-3200 facebook.com/southoldfishmarket
Winner 2022: Fit-Foods
Fit-Foods 46025 County Rd 48 Southold (631) 765-8199 fitfoodsnofo.com
Winner 2022: Love Lane Kitchen
Love Lane Kitchen 240 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-8989 lovelanekitchen.com
Winner 2022: Founders Tavern
Founders Tavern 55500 NY-25 Southold (631) 765-3100 founderstavern.com
Winner 2022: Riverhead Ciderhouse Hard Cider
Riverhead Ciderhouse Hard Cider 2711 Sound Ave Calverton (631) 591-0217 riverheadcider.com
Winner 2022: Front Street Station
Front Street Station 212 Front St Greenport (631) 333-2050 eatatfrontstreet.net
Winner 2022: The Original Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
The Original Goldberg’s Famous Bagels 10095 Main Rd Mattituck (631) 315-5238 theoriginalgoldbergsbagels.com