Winner 2024: Maple Tree BBQ
Maple Tree BBQ 820 West Main St Riverhead (631) 727-2819 mapletreebbq.com
Winner 2024: Polka Deli
Polka Deli 125 W Main St Riverhead (631) 369-2102
Winner 2023: Greenport Wines and Spirits Greenport Wines
Greenport Wines and Spirits Greenport Wines 132 Front St Greenport (631) 477-6701 greenportwinesandspirits.com
Hall of Fame: Towne Cellars
Towne Cellars 460 County Rd 111, Suite 13 Manorville (631) 874-0451 townecellarswines.com
Hall of Fame: Main Road Biscuit Co.
Main Road Biscuit Co. 1601 Main Rd Jamesport (631) 779-3463 mainroadbiscuitco.com
Winner 2023: Riverhead Farmers Market
Riverhead Farmers Market 139 Main Rd Riverhead (631) 632-5129 localline.ca/eastendfood
Winner 2023: Greenport Harbor Brewery and Restaurant
Greenport Harbor Brewery and Restaurant 42155 Main Rd Peconic (631) 477-1100 greenportharborbrewing.com
Winner 2023: The Giving Room
The Giving Room 56215 Rte 25 Southold (631) 765-6670 givingroom.net
Winner 2023: Black Sheep Bagels
Black Sheep Bagels Multiple Locations (631) 779-2914 blacksheepbagelsnf.com
Winner 2023: Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts
Love Lane Sweet Shoppe & Gifts 125 Love Ln Mattituck (631) 298-2276 lovelanesweets.com