Winner 2025 (Tie): 1943 Pizza Bar
1943 Pizza Bar 308 Main St Unit D, Greenport (631) 477-6984 rollingindoughpizza.com/1943-pizza
Winner 2025 (Tie): Caruso’s Pizzeria
Caruso’s Pizzeria 1104 Old Country Road, Riverhead (631) 369-2850 carusospizzariverhead.com
Winner 2024: 1943 Pizza Bar
1943 Pizza Bar 308 Main St Unit D Greenport (631) 477-6984 rollingindoughpizza.com/1943-pizza
Winner 2023: Caruso’s (Tie)
Caruso’s 1104 Old Country Rd Riverhead (631) 369-2850 carusospizzariverhead.com
Winner 2023: Sergio’s Pizza (Tie)
Sergio’s Pizza 739 Old Country Rd Riverhead (631) 369-1057 sergiosnypizza.com
Winner 2022: Caruso’s Pizzeria
Caruso’s Pizzeria 1104 Old Country Rd Riverhead (631) 369-2850 carusospizzariverhead.com
Winner 2021: Pizza Rita
Pizza Rita55 Middle RdMattituck631-315-5557pizzarita.org