Winner 2024: Jerry and the Mermaid
Jerry and the Mermaid 469 East Main Street Riverhead (631) 727-8489 jerryandthemermaid.com
Winner 2023: Pearl Restaurant & Bar
Pearl Restaurant & Bar 409 Main Street Greenport (631) 333-2888 pearlrestaurantbargreenport.com
Winner 2022: Jerry and the Mermaid
Jerry and the Mermaid 469 E Main St Riverhead (631) 727-8489 jerryandthemermaid.com
Winner 2021: Spicy’s BBQ
Spicy’s BBQ225 W Main StRiverhead631-727-2781 facebook.com/spicysbbq