Winner 2025: The Vineyards at Aquebogue
The Vineyards at Aquebogue 978 Main Road, Riverhead (631) 722-3200 lessings.com
Winner 2024: Brecknock Hall
Brecknock Hall 1 Brecknock Rd Greenport (631) 593-8200 brecknockhall.com
Winner 2023: Brecknock Hall
Brecknock Hall 1 Brecknock Rd Greenport (631) 593-8200 brecknockhall.com
Winner 2022: Giorgio’s Baiting Hollow (Tie)
Giorgio’s Baiting Hollow 100 Fox Hill Dr Baiting Hollow (631) 727-6076 giorgiosli.com
Winner 2022: Brecknock Hall (Tie)
Brecknock Hall 1 Brecknock Rd Greenport (631) 593-8200 brecknockhall.com
Winner 2021: Jedediah Hawkins Inn
Jedediah Hawkins Inn400 S Jamesport AveJamesport631-722-2900 jedediahhawkinsinn.com