Winner 2025: North Fork Adventures Charters
North Fork Adventures Charters 64300 Main Rd, Southold (516) 662-6382 northforkadventures.com
Winner 2024: North Fork Adventures Charters
North Fork Adventures Charters 64300 Main Rd Southold (516) 662-6382 northforkadventures.com
Winner 2023: Captain Bob Fishing Fleet (Tie)
Captain Bob Fishing Fleet 5675 West Mill Rd Mattituck (631) 298-5522 captbobfishingfleet.com
Winner 2023: The Peconic Star Fleet (Tie)
The Peconic Star Fleet 103 Third St Greenport (631) 875-2631 peconicstarboats.com
Winner 2022: The Peconic Star Fleet
The Peconic Star Fleet 103 Third St Greenport (631) 875-2631 peconicstarboats.com
Winner 2021: Captain Bob Fishing Fleet
5675 West Mill Rd, Mattituck631-298-5522 captbobfishingfleet.com