Winner 2025: Love Lane Kitchen
Love Lane Kitchen 240 Love Ln, Mattituck (631) 298-8989 lovelanekitchen.com
Winner 2024: Country Corner Café
Country Corner Café 55765 Main Rd Southold (631) 765-6766 countrycornersouthold.com
Hall of Fame: Main Road Biscuit Co.
Main Road Biscuit Co. 1601 Main Rd Jamesport (631) 779-3463 mainroadbiscuitco.com
Winner 2023: Cutchogue Diner
Cutchogue Diner 27850 Main Rd Cutchogue (631) 734-7016 cutchoguediner.com
Winner 2022: Main Road Biscuit Co.
Main Road Biscuit Co. 1601 Main Rd Jamesport (631) 779-3463 mainroadbiscuitco.com
Winner 2021: Cutchogue Diner
Cutchogue Diner27850 Main RdCutchogue631-734-7016 cutchoguediner.com