Winner 2025: Front Street Station
Front Street Station 212 Front St, Greenport (631) 333-2050 eatatfrontstreet.net
Winner 2024: The Frisky Oyster
The Frisky Oyster 27 Front St Greenport (631) 477-4265 thefriskyoyster.com
Winner 2023: Pearl Restaurant & Bar
Pearl Restaurant & Bar 409 Main St Greenport (631) 333-2888 pearlrestaurantbargreenport.com
Winner 2022: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 1st St New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2021: Pearl Restaurant & Bar
Pearl Restaurant & Bar409 Main StGreenport631-333-2888 pearlrestaurant409.square.site