Winner 2024: North Fork Roasting Co.
North Fork Roasting Co. 55795 Main Rd Southold (631) 876-5450 northforkroastingco.com
Winner 2024: American Beech
American Beech 300 Main Street Greenport (631) 477-5939 americanbeech.com
Hall of Fame: Tweed’s Restaurant & Buffalo Bar
Tweed’s Restaurant & Buffalo Bar 17 East Main St Riverhead (631) 237-9120 tweedsrestaurantriverhead.com
Hall of Fame: Mazzu’s Catering
Mazzu’s Catering 120 Wooleys Dr Southampton (631) 726-2044 mazzuscatering.com
Hall of Fame: Main Road Biscuit Co.
Main Road Biscuit Co. 1601 Main Rd Jamesport (631) 779-3463 mainroadbiscuitco.com
Winner 2023: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 First St New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2023: Stirling Sake
Stirling Sake 477 Main St Greenport (631) 477-6782 stirlingsake.com
Winner 2023: Pearl Restaurant & Bar (Tie)
Pearl Restaurant & Bar 409 Main St Greenport (631) 333-2888 pearlrestaurantbargreenport.com
Winner 2023: Aldo’s Coffee Company
Aldo’s Coffee Company 103-105 Front St Greenport (631) 477-6300 aldos.com
Winner 2023: Cooperage Inn (Tie)
Cooperage Inn 2218 Sound Ave Calverton (631) 727-8994 cooperageinn.com