Winner 2025: Kessie
Kessie 25 Front St Greenport (631) 477-6900 greenportvillage.com/kessie
Winner 2024: The Jewelry Box & Gift Shoppe
The Jewelry Box & Gift Shoppe 5768 Rt. 25A Ste 1 Wading River (631) 929-9400
Hall of Fame: Robert’s Jewelers
Robert’s Jewelers Gone but not forgotten
Winner 2023: Common Ground Jewelry
Common Ground Jewelry 123 Main St Ste C Greenport www.commongroundjewelry.com
Winner 2022: Common Ground Fine Jewelry
Common Ground Fine Jewelry 123 Main St Ste C Greenport commongroundjewelry.com
Winner 2021: Satnick Jewelers
Satnick Jewelers53345, Main RdSouthold631-765-1061