Winner 2024: Cowfish
Cowfish 258 E Montauk Hwy Hampton Bays (631) 594-3868 cowfishrestaurant.com
Winner 2023: John’s Drive-In (Tie)
John’s Drive-In 677 Montauk Hwy Montauk (631) 668-5515 johnsdriveinmontauk.com
Winner 2023: Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More (Tie)
Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More 199 Pantigo Rd East Hampton (631) 604-6470 smokinwolfbbq.com
Winner 2022: John’s Drive-In (Tie)
John’s Drive-In 677 Montauk Hwy Montauk (631) 668-5515 johnsdriveinmontauk.com
Winner 2021: Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More
Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More 199 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 631-604-6470 smokinwolfbbq.com