Winner 2025: East End Lobster Bake
East End Lobster Bake PO Box 2548, Southampton (631) 830-3060 eastendlobsterbake.com
Winner 2024: Haskell’s Seafood Market and Cafe
Haskell’s Seafood Market and Cafe 77 Main St Westhampton Beach (631) 288-7287 haskellsseafood.com
Winner 2023: Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More (Tie)
Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More 199 Pantigo Rd East Hampton (631) 604-6470 smokinwolfbbq.com
Winner 2022: Manna at Lobster Inn
Manna at Lobster Inn 5 Inlet Rd W Tuckahoe (631) 728-5555 mannarestaurant.com
Winner 2021: Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More
Smokin’ Wolf BBQ & More 199 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 631-604-6470 smokinwolfbbq.com