Winner 2025: JC’s Restaurant Manorville
JC’s Restaurant Manorville 2 Country Club Drive, Manorville (631) 909-3525 jcsmanorville.com
Winner 2024: RUMBA Inspired Island Cuisine & Rum Bar
RUMBA Inspired Island Cuisine & Rum Bar 43 Canoe Place Rd Hampton Bays (631) 594-3544 rumbahamptonbays.com
Winner 2023: Jerri’s Cakery & Confections
Jerri’s Cakery & Confections 59 Montauk Hwy Westhampton (631) 223-8986 jerricakes.com
Winner 2022: Citarelli’s Market & Prime Meats
Citarelli’s Market & Prime Meats 525 Montauk Hwy Eastport (631) 325-0025 citarellismarket.com
Winner 2021: 78 Foster (Tie)
78 Foster 78 Foster Ave Hampton Bays 631-594-3967 78fosterhamptons.com
Winner 2021: Tate’s Bake Shop (Tie)
Tate’s Bake Shop 43 N Sea Rd Southampton 631-283-9830 tatesbakeshop.com