Winner 2025: Amaden Gay Agencies
Amaden Gay Agencies 11 Gay Rd, East Hampton (631) 324-0041 amadengay.com
Winner 2024: Amaden Gay Agencies
Amaden Gay Agencies 11 Gay Rd East Hampton (631) 324-0041 amadengay.com
Winner 2023: Amaden Gay Agencies
Amaden Gay Agencies 11 Gay Rd East Hampton (631) 324-0041 amadengay.com
Winner 2022: Dayton Ritz + Osborne Insurance
Dayton Ritz + Osborne Insurance 88 Main St Southampton (631) 283-2220 droinsurance.com
Winner 2021: Amaden Gay Agencies (Tie)
Amaden Gay Agencies 11 Gay Rd East Hampton 631-324-0041 amadengay.com
Winner 2021: Hamptons Risk Management Insurance Agency (Tie)
Hamptons Risk Management Insurance Agency 2228 Montauk Hwy, Unit A Bridgehampton 631-537-6767 hamptonsriskmgmt.com