Winner 2024: Edgewater Restaurant
Edgewater Restaurant 295 E Montauk Hwy Hampton Bays (631) 723-2323 edgewaterrestaurant.com
Winner 2023: II Capuccino Ristorante (Tie)
II Capuccino Ristorante 30 Madison St Sag Harbor (631) 725-2747 ilcaps11963.com
Winner 2023: Cappelletti Grill (Tie)
Cappelletti Grill 3284 Noyac Rd Sag Harbor (631) 725-7800 cappellettirestaurant.com
Winner 2022: Edgewater Restaurant (Tie)
Edgewater Restaurant 295 E Montauk Hwy Hampton Bays (631) 723-2323 edgewaterrestaurant.com
Winner 2022: II Capuccino Ristorante (Tie)
II Capuccino Ristorante 30 Madison St Sag Harbor (631) 725-2747 ilcaps.com
Winner 2021: II Capuccino Ristorante
II Capuccino Ristorante 30 Madison St Sag Harbor 631-725-2747 ilcaps.com
Winner 2020: Cappelletti
Cappelletti Restaurant Located at 3284 Noyac Rd Sag Harbor. This sweet little spot is only 5 minutes from Main Street Sag Harbor. Family owned and operated. Open 7 days 11 am-10 pm Sun ’til 9pm. Fresh Fish, Lobster Rolls, Steaks, Pasta, Salads, Burgers, Fresh veggies, Pizza, home baked muffins, cookies, tira mi su. Home of…