Winner 2024: Margarita Grille
Margarita Grille 83 Main St Westhampton Beach (631) 288-5252 themargaritagrille.com
Winner 2023: K Pasa
K Pasa 2 Main St Sag Harbor (631) 800-8226 1-800-taco.com
Winner 2022: K Pasa (Tie)
K Pasa 2 Main St Sag Harbor (631) 800-8226 1-800-taco.com
Winner 2022: Estia’s Little Kitchen (Tie)
Estia’s Little Kitchen 1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Tpke Sag Harbor (631) 725-1045 estias.com
Winner 2021: Coche Comedor
Coche Comedor 74 Montauk Hwy Amagansett 631-267-5709 cochecomedor.com