Winner 2025: ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop
ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop 17 Poxabogue Ln, Sagaponack (631) 537-3682 shop.arfhamptons.org
Winner 2024: ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop
ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop 17 Poxabogue Ln Sagaponack (631) 537-3682 shop.arfhamptons.org
Winner 2023: ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop
ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop 17 Poxabogue Ln Sagaponack (631) 537-3682 shop.arfhamptons.org
Winner 2022: LVIS
LVIS 95 Main St East Hampton (631) 324-1220 lvis.org
Winner 2021: Ava’s & Around Again
Ava’s & Around Again 1 Long Wharf St Sag Harbor 631-725-4067 avasaroundagain.com