Winner 2025: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 First St, New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2024: Touch of Venice
Touch of Venice 28350 Main Rd Cutchogue (631) 298-5851 touchofvenice.com
Winner 2023: Founders Tavern
Founders Tavern 55500 Rte 25 Southold (631) 765-3100 founderstavern.com
Winner 2022: CJ’s American Grill
CJ’s American Grill 10095 Main Rd Mattituck (631) 315-5311 cjsamericangrill.net
Winner 2021: Claudio’s
Claudio’s111 Main StGreenport631-477-0627 claudios.com