Winner 2025: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 First St, New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2024: Sophie’s
Sophie’s 730 Main Bayview Rd Southold (631) 765-5700
Winner 2023: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 First St New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2022: Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant 835 1st St New Suffolk (631) 734-5123 legends-restaurant.com
Winner 2021: Phil’s Restaurant and Sports Lounge
Phil’s Restaurant and Sports Lounge1856 Wading River Manor RdWading River631-929-0508 philsrestaurant.com