Winner 2024: Hooked
Hooked 34 S Etna Ave Montauk (631) 668-2111 hookedmtk.com
Winner 2023: Hooked
Hooked 34 South Etna Ave Montauk (631) 668-2111 hookedmtk.com
Winner 2022: Manna at Lobster Inn
Manna at Lobster Inn 5 Inlet Rd W Tuckahoe (631) 728-5555 mannarestaurant.com
Winner 2021: 78 Foster
78 Foster 78 Foster Ave Hampton Bays 631-594-3967 78fosterhamptons.com