Winner 2023: Hooked
Hooked 34 South Etna Ave Montauk (631) 668-2111 hookedmtk.com
Winner 2022: The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH 32 Montauk Hwy Southampton (631) 283-3460 lobsterroll.com/southampton
Winner 2021: Hooked Montauk
Hooked Montauk 34 South Etna Ave Montauk 631-668-2111 hookedmtk.com
Canal Cafe
Casual Waterfront Dining atmosphere, with not-so-casual food. Indoor and Outdoor dining, weather permitting. Catering for Private Parties.