Winner 2023: John’s Drive-In (Tie)
John’s Drive-In 677 Montauk Hwy Montauk (631) 668-5515 johnsdriveinmontauk.com
Winner 2023: Citarella
Citarella 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 20 Hampton Rd Southampton (631) 283-6600 citarella.com
Winner 2023: Jerri’s Cakery & Confections
Jerri’s Cakery & Confections 59 Montauk Hwy Westhampton (631) 223-8986 jerricakes.com
Winner 2023: Westhampton Beach Farmers Market
Westhampton Beach Farmers Market Westhampton Beach (631) 288-3337 westhamptonchamber.org
Winner 2023: Montauk Distilling Company
Montauk Distilling Company 24 East 2nd St Ste B Riverhead (631) 727-6326 montaukdistillingco.com
Winner 2023: Shock Ice Cream (Tie)
Shock Ice Cream 99 Main St Westhampton Beach (631) 553-0155 shockicecream.com
Winner 2023: Bliss Pastries LLC
Bliss Pastries LLC Huntington Station (917) 972-0377 blisspastries.com
Winner 2022: Bliss Pastries LLC
Bliss Pastries LLC Huntington Station (917) 972-0377 blisspastries.com
Winner 2022: Citarelli’s Market & Prime Meats
Citarelli’s Market & Prime Meats 525 Montauk Hwy Eastport (631) 325-0025 citarellismarket.com
Winner 2022: Manna at Lobster Inn
Manna at Lobster Inn 5 Inlet Rd W Tuckahoe (631) 728-5555 mannarestaurant.com