Winner 2023: Citarella

Citarella 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 20 Hampton Rd Southampton (631) 283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2021: Citarella

Citarella 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 631-283-6600 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 631-283-6600 20 Hampton Rd Southampton 631-283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2020: Citarella

Citarella Gourmet Market Celebrating 20 Years Serving the Hamptons Communities As a family run business, we’re driven by a passion for great food and the desire to help fill your family table with traditional, handcrafted favorites. Led by owner Joe Gurrera — and his commitment to superior quality — we have grown from a respected…