Skip to content
Facebook page opens in new windowX page opens in new windowInstagram page opens in new window
Dan’s Best of the Best
The Best Businesses on the East End of Long Island
Dan’s Best of the BestDan’s Best of the Best
  • Buy Winners Party Tickets
  • Promote Your 2025 Win
  • 2025 Winners
    • South Fork
    • North Fork
  • Promote Your 2025 Nomination
  • 2025 Vote Now
    • 2025 Voters Guide
    • NORTH FORK
    • SOUTH FORK
  • View the 2023 Winners Guide
  • Home
  • About Dime Bank
  • Contact
  • 2026 Nominate Now
Search:
  • Buy Winners Party Tickets
  • Promote Your 2025 Win
  • 2025 Winners
    • South Fork
    • North Fork
  • Promote Your 2025 Nomination
  • 2025 Vote Now
    • 2025 Voters Guide
    • NORTH FORK
    • SOUTH FORK
  • View the 2023 Winners Guide
  • Home
  • About Dime Bank
  • Contact
  • 2026 Nominate Now

Category Archives: Seafood Shop

Winner 2025: Citarella

Bakery, Butcher, Cheese Shop, Coffee, Deli, FOOD & DRINK, Fried Chicken, Gourmet Food Shop, Pizza, Raw Bar, Salad Bar, Seafood Shop, SHOPPING, South Fork, Supermarket, SushiBy Dan's Best of the Best TeamNovember 14, 2025

Citarella Multiple Locations (201) 705-7027

Winner 2024: Montauk Seafood Company

South Fork, FOOD & DRINK, Seafood ShopBy Dan's Best of the Best TeamAugust 23, 2024

Montauk Seafood Company 12 S Etna Ave Montauk (631) 668-5957 montaukseafoodcompany.com

Winner 2024: Citarella (Tie)

South Fork, Butcher, Cheese Shop, FOOD & DRINK, Fried Chicken, Gourmet Food Shop, Seafood Shop, SushiBy Dan's Best of the Best TeamAugust 23, 2024

Citarella 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 20 Hampton Rd Southampton (631) 283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2023: Citarella

South Fork, Bakery, Butcher, Cheese Shop, Coffee, Cupcakes, Deli, FOOD & DRINK, Fried Chicken, Gourmet Food Shop, Pizza, Raw Bar, Salad Bar, Seafood Shop, SushiBy Dan's Best of the Best TeamFebruary 23, 2024

Citarella 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 20 Hampton Rd Southampton (631) 283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2022: Citarella

South Fork, Butcher, Cheese Shop, Coffee, Cupcakes, Deli, FOOD & DRINK, Fried Chicken, Gourmet Food Shop, Pizza, Raw Bar, Salad Bar, Seafood Shop, SHOPPING, Supermarket, SushiBy Dan's Best of the Best TeamFebruary 24, 2023

Citarella East Hampton, Bridgehampton, Southampton (631) 283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2021: Citarella

Bakery, Butcher, Cheese Shop, Coffee, Cupcakes, Deli, FOOD & DRINK, Fried Chicken, Gourmet Food Shop, Pizza, Raw Bar, Salad Bar, Seafood Shop, South Fork, SushiBy Celeste AlaminFebruary 25, 2022

Citarella 2209 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton 631-283-6600 2 Pantigo Rd East Hampton 631-283-6600 20 Hampton Rd Southampton 631-283-6600 citarella.com

Winner 2020: Citarella

Seafood Shop, South ForkBy Josh SchnepsFebruary 28, 2021Leave a comment

Citarella Gourmet Market Celebrating 20 Years Serving the Hamptons Communities As a family run business, we’re driven by a passion for great food and the desire to help fill your family table with traditional, handcrafted favorites. Led by owner Joe Gurrera — and his commitment to superior quality — we have grown from a respected…

© 2026 Dan's Best of the Best / Dan's Hamptons LLC

Terms & Conditions

Go to Top