Winner 2025: The Farmhouse Bed and Breakfast
The Farmhouse Bed and Breakfast 1855 Depot Ln, Cutchogue (631) 734-8539 thefarmhousebedandbreakfast.com
Winner 2024: Aqua by American Beech
Aqua by American Beech 15 Bay Ave Aquebogue (631) 722-3212 aquahotelbeachclub.com
Winner 2023: Harvest Inn
Harvest Inn 40300 Main Rd Peconic (631) 765-9412 theharvestinnnofo.com
Winner 2022: Harvest Inn
Harvest Inn 40300 Main Rd Peconic (631) 765-9412 theharvestinnnofo.com
Winner 2021: Aqua by American Beech (Tie)
Aqua by American Beech15 Bay AveAquebogue631-722-3212 aquahotelbeachclub.com
Winner 2021: Bayview Inn (Tie)
Bayview Inn 46 Front StSouth Jamesport631-779-3454 baybreezeinnli.com